Underline or highlight words, sentences, and passages that stand out, for whatever reason. Underline the key arguments that you believe the author of the text is making, and mark any evidence, examples, and stories that seem interesting or important. You might want to differentiate the evidence from the main ideas by using a different color marker or indicating the difference in another way. But don’t be afraid to “get it wrong.” There is no right or wrong here. The sentences in the text that you underline may be the same or different from those noticed by your classmates, and this difference of interpretation is the essence of critical reading. Consider using different colored highlighters or pens for the various categories of the writing, such as new vocabulary, main ideas, and important examples. Otherwise, you risk turning your text into one big underline or highlight of the same color. It is also a good idea to re-state main ideas in your own words. This acts as a comprehension check and gives you a start on any writing you may do later.
Annotation
If you merely read a text, start to finish, and don’t write anything, you won’t have a good understanding of what you read. Sure, you might know the main point the author was trying to make, and that may be good enough if you’re reading for fun, but it’s not good enough for college.
Annotating is good for a number of reasons. It helps you in:
- staying engaged and connected while you read
- making sure you understand what you read
- finding the main points and how the text is organized
- identifying and sorting information for an assignment
- remembering what you read and thought about, at that time.
No matter what you are annotating, you should be writing on the same page, next to what’s printed, on sticky notes, or on a double-entry journal. Annotating consists of many different practices: writing notes in the margins of the page, jotting symbols in the margins next to passages, underlining sentences, circling words, paraphrasing etc.
Key: We annotate differently depending on the purpose.
There are four general reasons for annotation.
1. When you annotate for ENGAGEMENT, your priority is to keep focused on, and emotionally and intellectually connected to, what you are reading.
|
What you might do or think: What you might write:
|
|
Respond to the text emotionally
|
Inspiring :-) Discouraging :-(
|
|
Relate to the text
|
Ref. Psych Prof. point about anxiety
Me in 9th grade
|
|
Visualize information or concept
|
Doodle or draw a picture to remind yourself quickly.
|
|
Ask questions
|
How does this compare to middle-class students?
|
| Observations about text |
Disagree (with the opinion he just described) |
|
Predict what is coming next
|
I think the character will....
|
|
Connect with other knowledge
|
Different cause/effect than Wise describes
|
2. When you realize you are confused, you need some strategies for COMPREHENSION.
|
What you might do or think: What you might write:
|
|
You don’t understand a word or term, so you go back and reread the sentence and figure it out – or you look it up.
|
Circle the word, and, after you figure out its meaning, write the meaning next to the word.
|
|
You don’t understand a word, but realize you can keep reading and still understand.
|
Circle the word and look it up later.
|
|
You don't understand what the author is saying as it applies to that particular situation.
|
Write your question next to the text and bring it up in class or with a tutor.
|
3. When you are annotating to find the author’s MAIN POINTS, you will need to identify the supporting points and details used to build the argument in order to discuss and write about it. This is also a helpful check for your understanding, especially if you try to rewrite the main points in your own words.
|
What you might do or think: What you might write:
|
|
You find the sentence that seems to be the main idea of a paragraph.
|
Underline and paraphrase it briefly.
|
|
You don’t see the main point actually written there, but you know what it is.
|
Paraphrase it.
|
|
The author says she has three reasons for her point, so you decide to make sure you can find all three.
|
Write “3 reasons” in the margin, and underline and number the reasons – 1, 2, 3 – when you find them.
|
|
The author gives examples for her point.
|
Underline them and write “ex” and draw an arrow to the point that the example is supporting.
|
4. When you annotate to find details and INFORMATION to use in your ESSAY, you will want to start to organize that information right on the page itself.
|
What you might do or think: What you might write:
|
|
You find a statistic showing that more first generation students than ever are going to college.
|
Underline the statistic and write
1st gen population > ever
|
|
You find a quote or detail that supports the idea that wages of people of color were rising in the '60s due to affirmative action
|
Underline it and write
aff. action 60s ups wages
|
Read over your annotations to help you remember what you read and THOUGHT!
Taking Notes
Take notes on the margins of the text. If you do not want to write on your book or journal, attach post-it notes with your comments to the text. If your source is electronic, use the highlighting and commenting functions available in many e-readers. Try to avoid reading text on your phone because the screen is small, and cell phones don't generally have annotation capabilities. Do not be afraid to write too much. This is the stage of the reading process during which you are actively finding meaning. Writing about what you read is the best way to make sense of it, especially, if the text is difficult. Writing about what you read will help you not only to remember the argument that the author is trying to advance, but it will also help you create your own interpretations of the text you are reading.
Here are some things you can do in your comments:
- Ask questions.
- Identify unknown vocabulary.
- Agree or disagree with the author.
- Question the evidence presented in the text.
- Offer counter-evidence.
- Offer additional evidence, examples, stories, etc. that support the author’s argument.
- Mention other texts that advance the same or similar arguments.
- Mention personal experiences that enhance your reading of the text.
Keep a Double-Entry Journal
Many writers like double-entry journals because they allow us to make that leap from summary of a source to interpretation and persuasion. To start a double-entry journal, divide a page into two columns. As you read, in the left column write down interesting and important words, sentences, quotations, and passages from the text. (Be sure to include the page number to make it easier for yourself later if you use it in your writing.) In the right column, write your reaction and responses to the passages. Be as formal or informal as you want. Record words, passages, and ideas from the text that you find useful, interesting, or in any way striking or unusual. Quote or summarize in full, accurately, and fairly. In the right-hand side column, ask the kinds of questions and provide the kinds of responses that will later enable you to create an original reading of the text, and use that reading to create your own paper.